Court of Justice of the European Union

 
 

Overview of judgments and pending cases of the Court of Justice of the European Union
(December 2022)

Our special thanks go to the website of the Centre for Migration Law of the Radboud University Nijmegen that offer support and further information in their overview of judgments and pending cases of the CJEU. This overview has gradually been built up and edited by Carolus Grütters, Helen Oosterom and Kees Groenendijk.

Table of contents

Immigration of EU citizens


Immigration of third-country nationals

Immigration of Turkish nationals

Schengen and visa rules

Asylum

Expulsion of third country nationals

 

Immigration of EU citizens ____________________________________________

 

Judgments  Date  Case number  ECLI:EU:C:  Subject
Dir
2004/38
TFEU Reg 492/2011
G.V. / LUX 08/12/2022 C-731/21 2022:969 - -  7(2)
M.C.M. / SWE 24/11/2022 C-638/20 2022:916 - 45  7(2)
S.R.S. & A.A. / IRLAND  15/09/2022   2022:683 3 -  
 E.K. / NL  07/09/2022 C-624/20  2022:194   20  
 S. /  GER  01/08/2022 C-411/20 2022:602 6, 24(2) 20  
 K.S. & S.V.D / POL  24/06/2022 C-2/21 2022:502 4(3) 20, 21  
N.W. / AT 26/04/2022 C-368/20 2022:298   21(1)  
X.U. a. Q.P. / ESP 05/05/2022 C-451/19
C-532/19
2022:354   20  
 K.R. / NL (withdrawn) 29/04/2022 C-637/21 2022:390 16(4)    
 Delia / 28/04/2022 C-86/21 2022:310    45 7(2)
 W.Y. / AT
(no jurisdiction)
15/05/2022 C-85/21 2022:192    21  
 V.I. / UK 10/03/2022 C-247/20 2022:177  Art 7(1), 16(1)  21  
 J.Y. / AUT  18/01/2022  C-118/20 2022:34  -  20, 21  
 VMA / Bulgaria 14/12/2021  C-490/20 2021:1008   18, 20, 21  
 X . / France
(withdrawn)
29/10/2021  C-206/21 2021:920  7(1)(b), 8(4)    
 A. / Finland 06/10/2021  C-35/20 2021:813  4, 5 Art 21(1)  
 X. / BEL 02/09/2021  C-930/19 2021:657   Art 20, 21 Charter  
A. / LAT 15/07/2021 C-535/19 2021:595  7(1)(b), 24    
C.G. 15/07/2021 C-709/20 2021:602  7, 24    
 VAS ApS / DK 08/07/2021  C-71/20 2021:550    49, 54  
F.S. / NL 22/06/2021 C-719/19 2021:506   15(1)  
Ordre des barreaux a.o. 22/06/2021 C-718/19 2021:505 20, 21 -  -
W.S. 12/05/2021 C-505/19 2021:376 21 -  -
Katoen Natie Bulk Terminals NV  11/02/2021 C-407/19
C-471/19
2020:107    45  
 G.M.A. 17/12/2020 C-710/19 2020:1037 14(4), 15, 31  45  
 B.Y. 17/12/2020 C-398/19 2020:1032  18, 21    
 Z.W. / Heilbronn  19/11/2020  C-454/19 2020:947      
Jobcenter Krefeld 06/10/2020 C-181/19 2020:794  24(2)    10
R.H. 27/02/2020 C-836/18  2020:119   20  
A.T. 22/01/2020 C-32/19  2020:25  17(1)(a)    
Krah 10/10/2019 C-703/17  2019:850   45  7(1)
Bajratari 02/10/2019 C-93/18  2019:809 7(1)(b)    
Barjalon 02/10/2019 C-93/18  2019:809  3(1), 7(1)(b)  21(1)  
Dakneviciute 19/09/2019 C-544/18  2019:761  7(3), 16(1)(3)    
Chenchooliah 10/09/2019 C-94/18  2019:693 3(1),15(3),30,31    
Tarola 11/04/2019 C-483/17 2019:309 7(1)(a),7(3)(c) -  
Mahmoed a.o. (order) 10/01/2019 C-169/18 2019:5 5(2) -  
SM 26/03/2019 C-129/18
2019:248 2(2)(c); 3(2) - -
 Tjebbes a.o. 12/03/2019 C-221/17 2019:189  20 - -
Fremoluc (inadmis.) 20/09/2018 C-343/17 2018:754 22, 24 21,45,49 -
Rafael Prefeta 13/09/2018 C-618/16 2018:570 7(3) - -
Banger 12/07/2018 C-89/17 2018:570 3(2),15(1) - -
Diallo 27/06/2018 C-246/17 2018:499 10(1) - -
Deha Altiner 27/06/2018 C-230/17 2018:497 21(1) - -
Coman a.o. 05/06/2018 C-673/16 2018:835 2(2a),3,4 21 -
K.A. a.o. 08/05/2018 C-82/16 2018:308 - 20 -
K. & H.F. 02/05/2018 C-331/16 C-366/16 2018:296 27(2), 28(3)    
B. & Vomero 17/04/2018 C-316/16 
C-424/16
2018:256 28(2), (3) -  -
Gusa 20/12/2017 C-442/16 2017:862 7(1), (3), 14(4) 21 -
Lounes 14/11/2017 C-165/16 2017:862 3(1), 7, 16 21  -
Petrea 14/09/2017 C-184/16 2017:684 27-30, 31, 32 - -
E. 13/07/2017 C-193/16 2017:542 27  -  -
Bechtel 22/06/2017 C-20/16 2017:488 - 45 -
Aquino 15/03/2017 C-3/16 2017:209 28 267 -
Freitag 08/06/2017 C-541/15 2017:432 - 18,21 -
Chavez-Vilchez 10/05/2017 C-133/15 2017:354 - 20 7(2)
Depesme & Kerrou 15/12/2016 C-401...
403/15
2016:955 - 45 7(2)
Bragança 14/12/2016 C-238/15 2016:949 - - -
Velikova 07/09/2016 C-228/15 2015:641 - 20,21 -
Petruhhin 06/09/2016 C-182/15 2016:630 - 18,21 10
N.A. 30/06/2016 C-115/15 2016:487 13(2) 20+21 -
C.S. 13/09/2016 C-304/14 2016:674 - 20 -
Com./UK 14/06/2016 C-308/14 2016:436 7,14(2),
24(2)
- -
Com./NL 02/06/2016 C-233/14 2016:396 24(2) 18,20,21 -
Rendón Marín 13/09/2016 C-165/14 2016:675 - 20,21 -
Bensada Benallal 17/03/2016 C-161/15 2016:175 28,30,31 - -
Garcia-Nieto 25/02/2016 C-299/14 2015:366 24(2) - -
Delvigne 06/10/2015 C-650/13 2015:648 - 20(2)(b) -
Alima/11/ic 15/09/2015 C-67/14 2015:597 24(2)   4
Kuldip Singh a.o. 26/07/2015 C-218/14 2015:476 7(1)(b),
13(2)(a)
- -
Martens 26/02/2015 C-359/13 2015:118 - 20,21 -
Com./Belgium 05/02/2015 C-317/14 2015:63 - 45 -
Sean McCarthy a.o. 18/12/2014 C-202/13 2014:2450 10,35 - -
Dano a.o. 11/11/2014 C-333/13 2014:2358 24(1) - 4
Haralambidis 10/09/2014 C-270/13 2014:2185 - 45(1),(4) -
Ogieriakhi 10/07/2014 C-244/13 2014:2068 16(2) - -
Saint Prix 19/06/2014 C-507/12 2014:2007 7(3) 45 -
Rüffer 27/03/2014 C-322/13 2014:189 - 18,21 -
S. & G. 12/03/2014 C-457/12 2014:136 3,6,7 20,21 -
O. & B. 12/03/2014 C-456/12 2014:135 3,6,7 20,21 -
Reyes 16/01/2014 C-423/12 2014:16 2(2)(c) - -
M.G. 16/01/2014 C-400/12 2014:9 28(3)(a) - -
Onuekwere 16/01/2014 C-378/12 2014:13 16 - -
Alokpa & Moudoulou 10/10/2013 C-86/12 2013:645 - 20 -
Brey 19/09/2013 C-140/12 2013:565 7(1)(b) - -
Prinz & Seeberger 18/06/2013 C-523 +
585/11
2013:524 - 20,21 -
Hadj Ahmed 13/06/2013 C-45/12 2013:390 13(2)+14 18 10
Z.Z. 04/06/2013 C-300/11 2013:363 30(2) - -
Ymeraga 08/05/2013 C-87/12 2013:291 3(1) 20 -
Alarape & Tijani 08/05/2013 C-529/11 2013:290 - - 10
L.N. 21/02/2013 C-46/12 2013:97 7(2),24 45(2) -
O., S. & L. 06/12/2012 C-356 ... 357/11 2012:776 3(1) 20 -
Iida 08/11/2012 C-40/11 2012;691 - 20 -
Byankov 04/10/2012 C-249/11 2012:608 27 - -
Com./Austria 04/10/2012 C-75/11 2012:605 24 20, 21 -
Czop & Punakova 06/09/2012 C-147 ... 148/11 2012:538 16 - 10
Rahman a.o. 05/09/2012 C-83/11 2012:519 3(2) - -
Com./NL 14/06/2012 C-542/09 2012:346 - 45 7(2)
P.I. 22/05/2012 C-348/09 2012:300 28(3) - -
Ziolkowski & Szeja 21/12/2011 C-424 ... 425/10 2011:866 16 - -
Aladzhov 17/11/2011 C-434/10 2011:750 4,27 - -
Gaydarov 17/11/2011 C-430/10 2011:749 4,27 - -
Dereci 15/11/2011 C-256/11 2011:734 - 20 -
Dias 21/07/2011 C-325/09 2011:498 16 - -
McCarthy 05/05/2011 C-434/09 2011:277 - 21 -
Runevič-Vardyn 12/05/2011 C-391/09 2011:291 - 21 -
Ruiz Zambrano 08/03/2011 C-34/09 2011:124 - 20 -
Lassal 07/10/2010 C-162/09 2010:592 16 - -
Tsakouridis 23/11/2010 C-145/09 2010:708 28(3) - -
Teixeira 23/02/2010 C-480/08 2010:83 12 - -
Ibrahim 23/02/2010 C-310/08 2010:80 12 - -
Rottmann 02/03/2010 C-135/08 2010:104 - 20 -
Wolzenburg 06/10/2009 C-123/08 2009:616 - 18 -
Vatsouras & Koupatantze 04/06/2009 C-22 ...
23/08
2009:344 24(2) 18 -
Deniz Sahin 19/12/2008 C-551/07 2008:755 3,6,7 - -
Huber 16/12/2008 C-524/06 2008:724 - 18 -
Föster 18/11/2008 C-158/07 2008:630 - 18, 20 -
Metock 25/07/2008 C-127/08 2008:449 3(1) - -
Jipa 10/07/2008 C-33/07 2008:396 4+27 20 -
Pending cases  
S.O. / GER   C-684/22
C-686/22
    20  
S.N. a.o. / NL   C-540/22     56, 57  
N.W. / HU   C-420/20     20  
P.Q. / HU   C-528/22   - - -
Rheumahotel / AT   C-411/22        
Kinderrechtencoalitie / BEL   C-280/22     16,21 3(5), 6, 14
Z.K. a. M.S. / IRL   C-248/22   2(2), 3(2)    
NORDIC / BE   C-128/22   2, 4, 5, 27, 29    
C.U. a. N.D. / IT   C-112/22
C-223/22
    18, 45  
R.L. / GER   C-61/22     20  
X. / DK   C-689/21        
 X.X.X. / Belgium   C-607/21    2(2)    
 W.A. / Romania   C-491/21      26(2)  
G.V. / IRL   C-488/21    7(2)    
E.K. / NL  AG:17/03/2022 C-624/20 2022:194   20  
X. / NL  AG:16/06/2022 C-459/20  2022:475   20  
S. / Germany AG:16/12/2021 C-411/20 2021:1017 6, 24(2) 20  
N.W. / AUT  AG:06/10/2021 C-368/20  2021:821   21(1)  
             
             
             

Decisions on directives that have expired

  1. Council Directive 73/148/EEC of 21 May 1973on the abolition of restrictions on movement and residence within the Community for nationals of Member States with regard to establishment and the provision of services
  2. Council Directive 90/364/EEC of 28 June 1990 on the right of residence
Judgments  Date  Case number  ECLI:EU:C:  Subject
Dir
73/148
Dir
90/364
EC
 Zhu & Chen  19/10/2004  C-200/02  2004:639  x x Art. 18
Jia 09/01/2007 C-1/05 2007:1 x   Art. 43

 ↑ TOP    

 

 Immigration of third-country nationals __________________________________

1 Family Reunification

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C: Subject
X. / Belgium 17/11/2022 C-230/21 2022:887 Art 2(f), 10(3)(a)
M.E. / Belgium
(deleted)
12/09/2022 C-191/22 2022:700 Art 4(1)(c)
Germany / X.C. 01/08/2022 C-279/20 2022:618 Art 4(1)(c), 16(1)(a)
S.W. / GER
B.C. / GER
01/08/2022 C-273/20
C-355/20
2022:617 Art 10(3)(a)
Art 16(1)(b)
X. / Belgium 02/09/2021 C-930/19 2021:657 Art 15(3)
A. / Migrationsverket 04/03/20121 C-193/19 2021:168 Art 5(2)
B.O.L. (withdrawn) 14/10/2020 C-250/19 2020:841 Art 4, 18
B.S.,
B.M.M.,
B.M.O.
16/07/2020 C-133/19,
C-136/19,
C-137/19
2020:577 Art 4
T.B. 12/1272019 C-519/18 2019:1070 Art 10(2)
G.S. & V.G. 12/12/2019 C-381+382/18 2019:1072 Art 6(2)
X. 20/11/2019 C-706/18 2019:993 Art 2(d), 5(4), 11(2)
Y.Z. a.o. 14/03/2019 C-557/17 2019:203 Art 16(2)(a), 17
E. 13/03/2019 C-635/17 2019:192 Art 16(2)(a)
C. and A. 07/11/2018 C-257/17 2018:876 Art 3(3); Art 15(1+4)
K. 07/11/2018 C-484/17 2018:17 Art 15(1+4)
K. and B. 07/11/2018 C-380/17 2018:877 Art 3(2)(c); Art 12(1)
A. and S. 12/04/2018 C-550/16 2017:248 Art 2(f); Art 10(3)
Khachab 21/04/2016 C-558/14 2016:285 Art 3(1); Art 7(1)(c); Art 16(1)(a)
K. and A. 09/07/2015 C-153/14 2015:453 Art 7(2)
Noorzia 17/07/2014 C-338/13 2014:2092 Art 4(5)
Dogan 10/07/2014 C-138/13 2014:2066 Art 7(2)
O., S. and L. 06/12/2012 C‑356/11 and C‑357/11 2012:776 Art 4(1), Art 7(1)(c)
Imran (deleted) 10/06/2011 C-155/11 PPU 2011:387 Art 7(2)
Chakroun 04/03/2010 C-578/08 2010:117 Art 7(1)(c)
Parliament v Council 27/06/2006 C-540/03 2006:429 Art 4(1+6); Art 8(2)
Pending cases
ADDE et al. / FR   C-143/22    
C.R. / Austria   C-560/20   Art 2(f)+10(3)(a)+7(1)
BL, BC / Germany   C-355/20    

↑ TOP

2 Long-Term Residents

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C Subject
E.K. / Netherlands 07/09/2022 C-624/20 2022:639 Art 3(2)(e)
Z.K. / Austria 20/01/2022 C-432/20 2022:39 Art 9(2)
ASGI 28/10/2021 C-462/20 2021:894 Art 11(1)(f)
Oberösterreich / K.V 10/06/2021 C-94/20 2021:477 Art 11
Com. /Hungary 11/01/2021 C-761/19 2012:74 Art 11(1)(a)
INPS / V.R. 25/11/2020 C-303/19 2020:958 Art 11(1)(d)
U.Q. a.o. 09/03/2020 C-503/19,
C-592/19
2020:629 Art. 6(1)     [1]
W.T. 11/06/2020 C-448/19 2020:467 Art 12
X. 03/10/2019 C-302/18 2019:830 Art 5(1)(a)
Y.Z. a.o. 14/03/2019 C-557/17 2019:203 Art 16(2)(a), 17
López Pastuzano  07/12/2017 C-636/16  2017:949 Art 12
CGIL and INCA 02/09/2015 C-309/14 2015:523  
P. and S. 04/06/2015 C-579/13 2015:523 Art 5(2), 11(1)
Tümer 05/11/2014 C-311/13 2014:2337 Art 3(1), 11(1)
Tahir 17/07/2014 C-469/13 2014:2094 Art 2, 4(1), 7(1), 13
Mlamali 14/11/2013 C-257/13 2013:763 Art 11
Iida 08/11/2012 C-40/11 2012:691 Art 2 Nr 2a+3)
Singh 18/10/2012 C-502/10 2012:636 Art 3(2)(e)
Comm. v Netherlands 26/04/2012 C-508/10 2012:243 Art 14(2)
Kamberaj 24/04/2012 C-571/10 2012:233 Art 11 (1+4)
Ziebell 08/12/2011 C-371/08 2011:809 Art 12
Pending cases
N.W. / Hungary   C-420/22   Art 10(1);
Charta Art.7, 24, 47
E.F. / GE   C-129/22   Art. 14
C.U. & N.D. / IT   C-112/22
C-223/22
  Art. 11(1)(d)
T.E. / GER   C-829/21   Art 14, 15

↑ TOP

3 Researchers and Students

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C Subject
Konsul Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej 10/03/2021 C-949/19 2021:168 Art 34(5)
Fahimian 04/04/2017 C-544/15 2017:255  
Ben Alaya 10/09/2014 C-491/13 2014:2187  
Sommer 21/06/2012 C-15/11 2012:371  
Payir 24/11/2008 C-294/06 2008:36  

↑ TOP

 4 Single Permit

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C Subject
ASGI 28/10/2021 C-462/20 2021:894 Art 12(1)(g)
O.D. / INPS (Ital.) 02/09/2021 C-350/20 2021:659 Art 12(1)
INPS / W.S. 25/11/2020 C-302/19 2020:957 Art 12(1)(e)
Martinez Silva 21/06/2017 C-449/16 2017:485  
Pending cases
ASG)   C-462/20   Art 12(1)(e)

↑ TOP

 5 Social Security

  • Council Regulation (EC) No 859/2003 of 14/05/2003 extending the provisions of Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71 and Regulation (EEC) No 574/72 to nationals of third countries who are not already covered by those provisions solely on the ground of their nationality
  • Regulation (EU) No 1231/2010 of the European Parliament and of the Council
    of 24 November 2010 extending Regulation (EC) No 883/2004 and Regulation (EC) No 987/2009 to nationals of third countries who are not already covered by these Regulations solely on the ground of their nationality
Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C Subject
Koppany / Hungary 03/03/2021 C-523/20 2021:160  
Balandin 24/01/2019 C-477/17 2019:60  
Wieland & Rothwangl 27/10/2016 C-465/14 2016:820  
Xhymshiti 18/11/2010 C-247/09 2010:698  

 ↑ TOP    

6 Posting of workers

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C Subject
Meat et al. 18/06/2015 C‑586/13 2015:15  Art 1(3)(c) Dir. 96/71/EC
Vicoplus SC PUH et al. 10/02/2011 C‑307/09 bis C-309/09 2011:64  Art 56, 57 TFEU
Vítor Manuel dos Santos Palhota et al. 07/10/2010 C‑515/08 2010:589 Art 56, 57 TFEU
RANI Slovakia 16/06/2010 C‑298/09  2010:343  Art 49-54 EC
Kommission/
Österreich
21/09/2006 C‑168/04 2006:595 Art 49 EC
Kommission/
Deutschland
19/01/2006 C‑244/04 2006:49 Art 49 EC
Kommission/
Luxemburg
21/10/2004 C‑445/03 2004:655 Art 49 EC
Portugaia Construções Ltd 24/01/2002 C-164/99 2002:40 Minimum wage
Mazzoleni et al. 15/03/2001 C-165/98 2001:162 Minimum wage
Arblade et al. 23/11/1999 C-369/96 und C-376/96 1999:575 Art 49, 50 EC
Vander Elst 09/08/1994 C-43/93 1994:310 Art 59, 60 EEC-Treaty
Rush Portuguesa 27/03/1990 C‑113/89 1990:142 Art. 558-66 EEC-Treaty
Webb 17/12/1981 C-279/80  1981:314  Art. 59, 60 EEC-Treaty

↑ TOP

 Immigration of Turkish nationals________________________________________

 Decisions of the Association Council

  • Decision No 1/80 of the Association Council of 19 September 1980 on the Development of the Association [ACD 1/80]
  • Decision No 3/80 of the Association Council of 19 September 1980 on the application of the social security schemes of the Member States of the European Communities to Turkish workers and members of their families [ACD 3/80]
  • Additional Protocol and Financial Protocol signed on 23 November 1970, annexed to the Agreement establishing the Association between the European Economic Community and Turkey and on measures to be taken for their entry into force - Final Act - Declarations [AP]
  • Decision No 2/76 of 20 December 1976 adopted by the Association Council set up by the Agreement establishing an Association between the European Economic Community and Turkey
Judgments  Date  Case number  ECLI:EU:C:  Subject
ACD 1/80 ACD 3/80 AP
S., E. & C. /  NL 09/02/2023 C-402/21 2023:77 Art 13, 14  
TBI Bank / DK 02/09/2021 C-379/21  2020:660 Art 13    
B.Y. a.o. / St. Duisburg 03/06/2021 C-194/20 2021:436 Art 6, 7, 9    
G.R. / St. Duisburg 21/10/2020 C-720/19  2020:847  Art 7(1)    
Solak 13/02/2020 C-258/18  2020:98    Art 6  
A., B. & P. 02/10/2019 C-70/18 2019:823  Art 13    
A. 10/07/2019 C-89/19  2019:580 Art 13  
Coban 15/05/2019 C-677/19 2019:408    Art 6  
Yön 07/08/2018 C-123/17 2018:632 Art 7 ACD 2/76  
Tekdemir 29/03/2017 C-652/15 2017:239 Art 13    
Ucar a.o. 21/12/2016 C-508...509/15 2016:986 Art 7    
Genc (Caner) 12/04/2016 C-561/14 2016:247 Art 13    
Demirci a.o. 14/01/2015 C-171/13 2018:8   Art 6  
Essent 11/09/2014 C-91/13 2014:2206 Art 13   Art 41
Dogan (Naime) 10/07/2014 C-138/13 2014:2066     x
Demir 07/11/2013 C-225/12 2013:725 Art 13    
Demirkan 24/09/2013 C-221/11 2013:583     Art 41(1)
Gülbahce 08/11/2012 C-268/11 2012:695 Art 6    
Dülger 19/07/2012 C-451/11 2012:504 Art 7(1)    
Kahveci & Inan 29/03/2012 C-7...9/10 2012:180 Art 7(1)    
Ziebell 08/12/2011 C-371/08 2011:809 Art 14    
Dereci a.o. 15/11/2011 C-256/11 2011:734     x
Baris Ünal 29/09/2011 C-187/10 2011:623 Art 6    
Tural Oguz 21/07/2011 C-186/10 2011:509     X
Pehlivan 16/06/2011 C-484/07 2011:395 Art 7(1)    
Akdas 26/05/2011 C-485/07 2011:346   Art 6  
Bozkurt (Metin) 22/12/2010 C-303/08 2010:800 Art 7(1)    
Toprak & Oguz 02/12/2010 C-300...301/09 2010:756 Art 13    
Com./Netherlands 29/04/2010 C-92/07 2010:228 Art 13   x
Genc (Hava) 04/02/2010 C-14/09 2010:57 Art 6    
Bekleyen 21/01/2010 C-462/08 2010:30 Art 7(2)    
Sahin 17/09/2009 C-242/06 2009:554 Art 13    
Soysal & Savatli 19/02/2009 C-228/06 2009:101     X
Altun 18/12/2008 C-337/07 2008:744 Art 7(1)    
Er 25/09/2008 C-453/07 2008:524 Art 7(1)    
Nihat Kahveci 25/07/2008 C-152/08 2008:450 Art 10(1)    
Payir a.o. 24/01/2008 C-294/06 2008:36 Art 6    
Polat 04/10/2007 C-349/06 2007:581 Art 14    
Tum & Dari 20/09/2007 C-16/05 2007:530     X
Derin 18/07/2007 C-325/05 2007:442 Art 7(2)    
Yedas Tarim/Council 05/07/2007 C-255/06 P 2007:414     X
Güzeli 26/10/2006 C-4/05 2006:670 Art 6(2)    
Torun 16/02/2006 C-502/04 2006:112 Art 7(2)    
Sedef 10/01/2006 C-230/03 2006:5 Art 6    
Gürol 07/07/2005 C-374/03 2005:435 Art 9    
Dogan (Ergül) 07/07/2005 C-383/03 2005:436 Art 6    
Aydinli 07/07/2005 C-373/03 2005:434 Art 7(1)    
Dörr & Ünal 02/06/2005 C-136/03 2005:340 Art 14    
Cetinkaya 11/11/2004 C-467/02 2004:708 Art 7(1)    
Ayaz 30/09/2004 C-275/02 2004:570 Art 7(1)    
Com./Austria 16/09/2004 C-465/01 2004:530 Art 10    
Öztürk 28/04/2004 C-373/02 2004:232   x  
Abatay & Sahin 21/10/2003 C-317/01,
C-369/01
2003:572 Art 13   x
Birlikte 08/05/2003 C-171/01 2003:260 Art 10    
Kurz (Yuce) 19/11/2002 C-188/00 2002:694 Art 6    
Bicakci 19/09/2000 C-89/00 - Art 14    
Eyüp 22/06/2000 C-65/98 2000:336 Art 7(1)    
Savas 11/05/2000 C-37/98 2000:224     Art 41
Ergat 16/03/2000 C-329/97 2000:133 Art 7(1)    
Kocak & Örs 14/03/2000 C-102/98 2000:119   x  
Nazli 10/02/2000 C-340/97 2000:77 Art 6/14    
Sürül 04/05/1999 C-262/96 1999:228 Art 3 Art 3  
Birden 26/11/1998 C-1/97 1998:568 Art 6    
Akman 19/11/1998 C-210/97 1998:555 Art 7(2)    
Günaydin 30/09/1997 C-36/96 1997:445 Art 6    
Ertanir 30/09/1997 C-98/96 1997:446 Art 6    
Kol 05/06/1997 C-285/95 1997:280 Art 6    
Eker 29/05/1997 C-386/95 1997:257 Art 6    
Kadiman 17/04/1997 C-351/95 1997:205 Art 7(1)    
Tetik 23/01/1997 C-171/95 1997:31 Art 6    
Taflan-Met a.o. 10/09/1996 C-277/94 1996:315   x  
Bozkurt (Ahmet) 06/06/1995 C-434/93 1995:168 Art 6    
Eroglu 05/10/1994 C-355/93 1994:369 Art 6    
Kus 16/12/1992 C-237/91 1992:527 Art 6    
Sevince 20/09/1990 C-192/89 1990:322 Art 6    
Demirel 30/09/1987 C-12/86 1987:400 Art 12 AO    36
Pending cases
X. / DK AG:08/09/2022 C-279/21  2022:652 Art 13    

  ↑ TOP      

Schengen and visa rules______________________________________________

1 Borders Code

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C: Subject

N.N. / AT

26/04/2022 C-368/20
C-369/20
2022:298 Art. 25, 29
A. / FIN 06/10/2021 C-35/20 2021:813 Art 20, 21(c)
M.A. / POL
10/03/2021 C-949/19 2021:186 Art. 21(2); Art. 47 Charter
A. / SWE 04/03/2021 C-193/19 2021:168 Art. 6(1)
F.U. 04/06/2020 C-554/19 2020:439 Art. 22, 23
Blue Air/D.Z. 30/04/2020 C-584/18 2020:324 Art. 14(2)
J. a.o. 05/02/2020 C-341/18 2020:76 Art 11
E.P. 12/12/2019 C-380/18 2019:1071 Art 6(1)(e)
Arib 19/03/2019 C-444/17 2019:220 Art 32
Touring Tours a.o 13/12/2018 C-412/17 + C-474/17 2018:1005 Art 22, 23
A 21/06/2017 C-9/16 2017:483 Art 20, 21
El Dakkak 04/05/2017 C-17/16 2017:341 Art 4(1)
Air Baltic 04/09/2014 C-575/12 2014:2155 Art 5
Zakaria 17/01/2013 C-23/12 2013:24 Art 13(3)
Jaao  [deleted] 14/09/2012 C-88/12 2012:573 Art 20,21
Parliament/Council 05/09/2012 C-355/10 2012:516  
Adil 19/07/2012 C-278/12 PPU 2012:508 Art 20, 21
ANAFE 14/06/2012 C-606/10 2012:348 Art 5(4), 13
Gaydarov 17/11/2011 C-430/10 2011:749  
Melki & Abdeli 22/06/2010 C-188+189/10 2010:206 Art 20, 21
Garcia & Cabrera 22/10/2009 C-261/08,
C-348/08
2009:648 Art 5, 11, 13
Pending cases
ADDE a.o. / FRA   C-143/22   Art 14

↑ TOP  

2 Visa Code

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C Subject
V.G. (withdrawn) 26/03/2021 C-121/20 2021:202 Art 22
R.N.N.S. & K.A. 24/11/2020 C-225/19
C-226/19
2020:951 Art 32(2)+(3)
Vethanayagam  29/07/2019 C-680/17 2019:627 Art 8(4), 32(3)
El Hassani 13/12/2017 C-403/16 2017:960 Art 32
X & X 07/03/2017 C-638/16 PPU 2017:173 Art 25(1)(a)
Air Baltic 04/09/2014 C-575/12 2014:2155  
Koushkaki 19/12/2013 C-84/12 2013:862  
Dang  [deleted] 18/06/2012 C-39/12 2012:359  
Vo 10/04/2012 C-83/12 2012:202 Art 21, 34
Pending cases

↑ TOP  

3 Visa List

  • Council Regulation (EC) No 539/2001 of 15 March 2001 listing the third countries whose nationals must be in possession of visas when crossing the external borders and those whose nationals are exempt from that requirement
Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C: Subject
Com./Parliament 16/07/2015 C-88/14 2015:499  Art 1(4)(f)
Pending cases        
Com./Parliament AG:15/12/2022 C-137/21 2022:989 Art 7(f)

↑ TOP  

4 Schengen Acquis

  •  The Schengen acquis - Convention implementing the Schengen Agreement of 14 June 1985 between the Governments of the States of the Benelux Economic Union, the Federal Republic of Germany and the French Republic on the gradual abolition of checks at their common borders
Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C: Subject
E. 16/01/2018 C-240/17  2018:8  Art 25(2)
Pending cases        

↑ TOP

5 Passports

  •  Council Regulation (EC) No 2252/2004 of 13 December 2004 on standards for security features and biometrics in passports and travel documents issued by Member States
Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C Subject
Willems a.o. 16/04/2015 C-446 ... 449/12 2015:238  
U. 02/10/2014 C-101/13 2014:2249  
Com./Belgium 13/02/2014 C-139/13 2014:80  
Schwarz 17/10/2013 C-291/12 2013:670  

↑ TOP  

6 Visa Information System

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C Subject
Jafari 26/07/2017 C-646/16 2017:443  
A.S. 26/0672017 C-490/16 2017:443  
Parlament / Rat 16/04/2015 C-540/13 2015:224  
Parlament / Rat 16/04/2015 C-317/13 2015:34  
Koushkaki 19/12/2013 C-84/12 2013:862  
Vo 10/04/2012 C-83/12 PPU 2012:202  
Vereinigtes Königreich / Rat 26/10/2010 C-482/08 2010:631  
Kommission / Deutschland 09/03/2010 C-518/07 2009:694  

 ↑ TOP

ASYLUM___________________________________________________________

1. Dublin II and III

  • Council Regulation (EC) No 343/2003 of 18 February 2003 establishing the criteria and mechanisms for determining the Member State responsible for examining an asylum application lodged in one of the Member States by a third-country national  [1]
  • Regulation (EU) No 604/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 establishing the criteria and mechanisms for determining the Member State responsible for examining an application for international protection lodged in one of the Member States by a third-country national or a stateless person  [2]
Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C Subject
C. & B. / NL 08/11/2022 C-39/21
C-704/20
2022:858 Art 28; Charta Art 47
O.T.E. 20/10/2022 C-66/21 2022:809 Art 17(1)
M.A., P.B., L.E. / GER 22/09/2022 C-245/21
C-248/21
2022:709 Art 27(4)
I. & S. / NL 01/08/2022 C-19/21 2022:605 Art 8(2), 27(1)             [2]
R.O. 01/08/2022 C720/20 2022:603 Art 20(1)
F. (withdrawn) 20/05/2022 C-208/22 2022:441  
I.A. / AUT 31/03/2022 C-231/21 2022:237 Art 29
G. / NL
(withdrawn)
15/03/2022 C-614/21 2022:252  
A. a.o. / GER
(withdrawn)
11/03/2022 C-504/21 2022:204  
A. 02/08/2021 C-262/21 PPU 2021:640 Art 6(1), 12(3)
H.A. / Belgium 15/04/2021 C-194/19 2021:270 Art 27
Fedasil ./ M.M. 03/12/2020 C-67/20 2020:1024 Art 27
I.N. 02/04/2020 C-879/19 PPU 2020:262  
H. & R. 02/04/2019 C-582/17, C-583/17 2019:280 Art 20(5), 27
Jawo 19/03/2019 C-163/17 2019:218 Art 29(2)
Ibrahim a.o. 19/03/2019 C-297/17, C-318/17, C-319/17, C-438/17  2019:219 Art 49  [2]
M.A. a.o. 23/01/2019 C-661/17 2019:53 Art 17
Alake a.o. (deleted) 11/01/2019 C-566/17 2019:69 Art 3(1); 23(1); 25(1)
X. & X. 13/11/2018 C-47+48/17 2018:900 Art (5)(2)
Fathi 04/10/2018 C-56/17 2018:821 Art 46(3)
X. 05/07/2018 C-213/17 2018:538 Art 23(3)
Adil Hassan 31/05/2018 C-647/16 2018:368 Art 26(1)
Aziz Hassan 25/01/2018 C-360/16 2018:35 Art 23, 24
Majid Shiri 25/10/2017 C-201/16 2017:805 Art 27(1)+29(1)+29(2)
Khir Amayry 13/09/2017 C-60/16 2017:675 Art 27(3)+(4)
Mengesteab 26/07/2017 C-670/16 2017:587 Art 21(1)+22(7)
Jafari 26/07/2017 C-646/16 2017:586 Art. 12+13
A.S. 26/07/2017 C-490/16 2017:585 Art 13(1)
Ahmed 05/04/2017 C-36/17 2017:273  
Al Chodor 15/03/2017 C-528/15 2017:213 Art 28
C.K. a.o. 16/02/2017 C-578/16 2017:127  
Karim 07/06/2016 C-155/15 2016:410 Art 19(2)
Ghezelbash 07/06/2016 C-63/15 2016:409  
Mirza 17/03/2016 C-695/15 PPU 2016:188 Art 3(3)
Abdullahi 12/12/2013 C-394/12 2013:813 Art 19(2)
Puid 04/11/2013 C-4/11 2013:740  
M.A. a.o. 02/09/2013 C-648/11 2013:367  
Halaf 30/05/2013 C-528/11 2013:342  
K. 06/11/2012 C-245/11 2012:685  
Kastrati 03/05/2012 C-620/10 2012:265  
N.S. & M.E. 21/12/2011 C-411+493/10 2011:865  
Petrosian 29/01/2009 C-19/08 2009:41  
Pending cases
A.H.Y. / Irland   C-359/22   Art 27
X. / NL   C-392/22    
O.V. / IT   C-217/22   Art. 4, 5
BU / IT   C-80/22    
X. / NL   C-745/21    
E. & S. / NL   C-568/21   Art 2
E.N. a.o. /NL  AG:17/11/2022 C-556/21  2022:901 Art 27(3), 29(1)
S., N. & S. / NL  AG:17/11/2022 C-338/21  2022:900 Art 29(1), 27(3)
B. / NL  AG:08/09/2022 C-323/21 -
C-325/21
2022:651 Art 27, 29
P.P. / IT   C-315/21   Art 4, 5, 27
XXX.XX / IT   C-297/21   Art 17(1),
Art 4, 19 Charter
D.G. / IT   C-254/21   Art 27
C.Z.A. / IT   C-228/21   Art 4, 27

↑ TOP

  2.   Qualification I and II

  • Council Directive 2004/83/EC of 29/04/2004 on minimum standards for the qualification and status of third country nationals or stateless persons as refugees or as persons who otherwise need international protection and the content of the protection granted   [1]
  • Directive 2011/95/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 December 2011 on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals or stateless persons as beneficiaries of international protection, for a uniform status for refugees or for persons eligible for subsidiary protection, and for the content of the protection granted  (recast)  [2]

 ↑ TOP

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C Subject
X. / NL
(withdrawn)
18/05/2022 C-579/20 2022:416 Art. 15(c)
N.B. a. A.B. / UK 03/03/2022 C-349/20 2022:151 Art 11, 12(1)(a)        [1]
X.X.X.X. / BEL 22/02/2022 C-483/20 2022:103 Art 23(2)                  [2]
L.W. / Germany 09/11/2021 C-91/20 2021:898 Art 3, 23(2)
ASGI 28/10/2021 C-462/20 2021:894 Art 29
S.E. / GER 09/09/2021 C-768/19 2021:709 Art 2(j), 11
C.F. & D.N. / GER 10/06/2021 C-901/19 2021:472 Art 2(f), 15(c)
Home dpt / O.A. 20/01/2021 C-255/19 2021;36 Art 2(e), 7, 11
Germany / X.T 20/01/2021 25/03/2021 2021:3 Art 12(1)(a)
E.Z. 19/11/2020 C-238/19 2020:945 Art 9(2) + 9(3)
Bilali 23/05/2019 C-720/17 2019:448 Art 19(1+3)   [2]
M. a.o. 14/05/2019 C-391/16, C-77/17, C-78/17 2019:403 Art 14(4-6)    [2]
Ibrahim a.o. 19/03/2019 C-297/17, C-318/17, C-319/17, C-438/17, C-318/17, C-319/17, C-438/17  2019:219 Art 33(2)(a), 52(1)   [2]
Ayubi 21/11/2018 C-713/17 2018:929 Art 29
Fahti 04/10/2018 C-56/17 2018:803  Art 9 (1+2)+10(1)(b)
Ahmedbekova 04/10/2018 C-652/16 2018:801  
Shajin Ahmed 13/09/2018 C-369/17 2018:713 Art 17(1)(b)
Alheto 25/07/2108 C-585/16 2018:584  Art 12(1)(a)
K. a.o. 12/05/2018 C-331/16, C-366/16 2018:296 Art. 27(2)
MP 24/04/2018 C-353/16 2018:276 Art 4(4)+15b
F. 25/01/2018 C-473/16 2018:36 Art 4+10(1)(d)
Lounani 31/01/2017 C-573/14 2016:380 Art 12
M. 09/02/2017 C-560/14 2016:320  
Danqua  20/10/2016 C-429/15  2016:789  
Alo & Osso 01/03/2016 C-443 ... 444/14 2016:127 Art 33+29
H.T. 24/06/2015 C-373/13 2015:413  
Shepherd 26/02/2015 C-472/13 2015:117  
Abdida 18/12/2014 C-562/13 2014:2453  
M’Bodj 18/12/2014 C-542/13 2014:2452  
A., B. & C. 02/12/2014 C-148 ... 150/13 2014:2406  
Qurbani 17/07/2014 C-481/13 2014:2101  
H.N. 08/05/2014 C-604/12 2014:302  
Diakite 30/01/2014 C-285/12 2014:39  
X., Y. & Z. 07/11/2013 C-199...201/12 2013:720  
El Kott 19/12/2012 C-364/11 2012:826  
M.M. 22/11/2012 C-277/11 2012:744  
Y. & Z. 05/09/2012 C-71/11 2012:558  
B. & D. 09/11/2010 C-57/09 2010:661  
Bolbol 17/06/2010 C-31/09 2010:351  
Abdulla a.o. 02/03/2010 C-175 ... 179/08 2010:105  
Elgafaji 17/02/2009 C-465/07 2009:94 Art 15c
Pending cases
M.A. / NL   C-402/22    
X.X.X. / BE        
S.W. / FR        
J.F. / AT   C-222/22   Art. 5(3)
S. & A. / NL   C-151/22   Art 10(1)
X. & Y. et al. / NL   C-125/22   Art 15(b); Charter Art 1, 4, 19(2)
X.X.X. / BE   C-8/22   Art 14(4)(b)
A.A. / AT   C-663/21   Art 9, 14(4)(b)
K. & L. / NL   C-646/21    Art 10(1)(d)     [2]
W.S. / Bulgaria   C-621/21   Art 17              [2]
P.I. / LIT AG:30/06/2022 C-280/21  2022:506 Art 10

↑ TOP

3  Asylum Procedures I and II

 

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C: Subject
B.U. / 01/12/2022 C-564/21 2022:951 Art 11, 23, 46
S.I. a.o. / GER 22/09/2022 C-497/21 2022:721 Art 2(g), 33(2)(d)
G.M. / HUN 22/09/2022 C-159/21 2022:708 Art 17(1)(b)
R.O. / GER 01/08/2022 C-720/20 2022:708 Art 33(2)(a)
T.O. / IT 01/08/2022 C-422/21 2022:616 Art 20(4),(59
M.A. / LT 30/06/2022 C-72/22 PPU 2022:505 Art. 4
X.X.X.X. / BEL 22/02/2022 C-483/20 2022:103 Art 33(2)
Com. / Hungary 16/11/2021 C-821/19 2021:930 Art 8, 12, 22, 33    [2]
X.Y. / AUT 09/09/2021 C-18/20 2021:710 Art 40, 42
  L.H. / NL 10/06/2021 C-921/19 2021:478 Art 40(2)      [2]
L.R. 20/05/2021 C-8/20 2021:404 Art 33(2)    [2]
T.H.C. 11/02/2021 C-755/19 2021:108 Art 46
Com. / Hungary 17/12/2020 C-808/18 2020:1029 CEAS measures
M.S. o.a. / Justice  10/12/2020 C-616/19  2020:1010 Art 25
E.M.T. (withdrawn) 16/10/2020 C-20/20 2020:892 Art 46
J.P. 09/09/2020 C-651/19 2020:681 Art 46
Addis 16/07/2020 C-517/17 2020:579 Art 14, 33(2)(a), 34  [2]
V.L. 25/06/2020 C-36/20 PPU 2020:495 Art 6, 26
F.M.S. a.o. 14/05/2020 C-924/19 PPU
C-925/19 PPU
2020:367  
L.H. 19/03/2020 C-564/18 2020:218 [2] Art 33, 46(3)
PG 19/03/2020 C-406/18 2020:216 {2] Art 46 (3)
Hamed & Omar 13/11/2019 C-540/17,
C-541/17
 2019:964  
Torubarov 29/07/2019 C-556/17  2019:339 [2] Art 46(3)
Ibrahim Bashar 19/03/2019

C-297/17, C-318/17, C-319/17,
C-438/17

2019:219 [2] Art 33(2)(a), 52
D. & I. (deleted) 15/11/2018 C-586/17 2018:964  
E.G. 18/10/2018 C-662/17 2018:847 [2]   Art 46(2)
Ahmedbekova 04/10/2018 C-652/16 2018:801 [1]   Art. 33(2)(e)
Fathi 04/10/2018 C-56/17 2018/803 [2]   Art 46(3)
FR 27/09/2018 C-422/18 PPU 2018:784  
X. & Y. 26/09/2018 C-180/17 2018:775  [1]   Art 39
X. 26/09/2018 C-175/17 2018:776  
Alheto 25/07/2018 C-585/16 2018:584  [2] Art 46(3)
A. 25/07/2018 C-404/17 2018:588  
C. & J. 05/07/2018 C-269/81 PPU 2018:544 [2]   Art 46(8)
Sacko 26/07/2017 C-348/16 2017:591  
Tall 17/12/2015 C-239/14 2015:824  
H.I.D. & B.A. 31/01/2013 C-175/11 2013:45 [1]   Art 23 + 39
Diouf 28/07/2011 C-69/10 2011:524  
Comm. 07/04/2011 C-431/10 2011:227 43
Parliament/Council 06/05/2008 C-133/06 2008:257  
Pending cases
X.X.X. / BE   C-614/22   Art 20, 23;
Charta Art 7, 24
S.N. & L.N. / BU   C-563/22    Art 14
AA. / GER   C-216/22   Art. 33(2), 40(2)
X. / IRL   C-756/21    
A. & B. / LUX   C-153/21   Art 33(2)      [2]Art 24 Charter
X. / BEL AG:30/09/2021 C-483/20 2021:780 Art 25(6), 33(2)
         

↑ TOP

4 Reception Conditions Directive I and II

Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C: Subject
C. & B. / NL 08/11/2022 C-39/21
C-704/20
2022:858 Art 19
H.N. / BU 15/09/2022 C-420/20 2022:679 Art 3, 9, 11(2)
T.O. / IT 01/08/2022 C-422/21 2022:616 Art 20(4)+(5)
M.A. / LT 30/06/2022 C-72/22 PPU 2022:505 Art 10(4)
Com. / Hungary 16/11/2021 C-821/19 2021:930 Art 10(4)
K.S. & M.H.K. 14/01/2021 C-322/19 2021:11 Art 15
V.L. 25/06/2020 C-36/20 PPU 2020:331 Art. 8
F.W. a.o. (deleted) 28/04/2020 C-726/18 2020:365 Art 20
Haqbin 12/11/2019 C-233/18 2019:956 Art 20
K. 14/09/2017 C-18/16 2017:680 Art 8(3)
J. N. 15/02/2016 C-601/15 PPUC-601/15 PPU 2016:84 Art 8
Saciri 27/02/2014 C-79/13 2014:103  
CIMADE & GISTI 27/09/2012 C-179/11 2012:594  
Pending cases

↑ TOP  

5. Provisional measures of protection for the benefit of Italy and Greece

  • Councel decision 2015/1523
    of 14 September 2015 establishing provisional measures in the area of international protection for the benefit of Italy and of Greece 
    [No longer in force, Date of end of validity: 17/09/2017]
  • Counsel Decision 2015/1601
    of 22 September 2015 establishing provisional measures in the area of international protection for the benefit of Italy and Greece 
    [No longer in force, Date of end of validity: 26/09/2017]
Judgments Date Case number ECLI:EU:C: Subject
Com / Poland, Hungary and Czech Republic 03/04/2020 C-715/17
C-718/17
C-719/17
2020:257  
Slovakia & Hungary / Council 06/09/2017 C-643/15,
C-647/15
2019:631 relocation decision is legally correct
Pending cases
  AG: 31/10/2019 C-715/17,
C-718/17,
C-719/17
2019:917 failing to fulfill obligations

↑ TOP  

Expulsion of third country nationals_____________________________________

 

Judgments  Date  Case number  ECLI:EU:C:  Subject
Dir
2008/115
Dir
2001/40
X. / NL 22/11/2022 C-69/21 2022:913 Art 5+9(1)(a)  
C. & B. / NL 08/11/2022 C-39/21
C-704/20
2022:858 Art 15(2)  
U.P. / BE 20/10/2022 C-825/21 2022:810 Art 6(4)  
I.L. / EST 06/10/2022 C-241/21 2022:753 Art 15(1)  
H.N. / BUL 15/09/2022 C-420/20 2022:679 Art 3, 9, 11(2)  
P.L
(unfounded)
08/09/2022 C-56/22 2022:679 Art 5, 6 11(29  
K. /GER 10/03/2022 C-519/20 2022:178 Art 16(1)  
U.N. / SPAIN 03/03/2022 C-409/20 2022:148 Art 6(1), 7(1,2), 8(1)  
B.Z. / GER 03/06/2021 C-546/19 2021:432 Art 2(29(b)+3(6)  
V.T. / CPAS 05/05/2021 C-641/20 2021:374 Art 5, 13  
M.A. / Belgium 11/03/2021 C-112/20 2021:197 Art. 5+13; Art. 23+47 Charter  
M. a.o. 24/02/2021 C-673/19 2021:127 Art. 3+4+6+15  
T.Q. 14/01/2021 C-441/19 2021:9 Art. 6+8+10  
Com. / Hungar 17/12/2020 C-808/18 2019:1029 Art 5+6 +12+13  
U.D. 04/12/2020 C-746/19 202:1029    
M.O. / Toledo 08/10/2020 C-568/19 2019:807    
L.M. / CPAS 30/09/2020 C-401/19 2019:579 Art 5+13 +14  
B. / CPAS 30/09/2020 C-233/19 2019:757 Art 5+13  
J.Z. 17/09/2020 C-806/18 2019:724 Art 11(2)  
W.M. 02/07/2020 C-18/19 2020:511 Art. 16(1)  
W.T. 11/06/2020 C-448/19 2020:467 Art 12  
Arib 19/03/2019 C-444/17 2019:220 Art 2(2)(a), Art 4(4)  
X. & Y. 26/09/2018 C-180/17 2018:775  Art 13  
X. 26/09/2018 C-175/17 2018:776    
Gnandi 19/06/2018 C-181/16 2018:465 Art 6(6)  
K.A. a.o. 08/05/2018 C-82/16 2018:308 x  
E. 16/01/2018 C-240/17 2018:8  x  
Petrea 14/09/2017 C-184/16 2017:684 x  
Nianga 11/08/2017  11/08/2017 C-199/16 2017:401 x  
Ouhrami 26/07/ 2017 C-225/16 2017:590  x  
Affum 07/06/2016 C-47/15 2016:408  x  
Bensada Benallal 17/03/ 2016 C-161/15 2016:175  x  
Celaj 01/10/2015 C-290/14 2015:640  x  
Orrego Arias 03/09/2015 C-456/14 2015:550    x
Zh. & O. 11/06/2015 C-554/13 2015:377  x  
Zaizoune 23/04/2015 C-38/14 2015:260  x  
Abdida 18/12/2014 C-562/13 2014:2453  x  
Boudjlida 11/12/2014 C-249/13 2014:2431  x  
Mukarubega 05/11/2014 C-166/13 2014:2336  x  
Pham 17/07/ 2014 C-474/13 2014:2096  x  
Bero & Bouzalmate 17/07/ 2014 C-473/13, C-514/13 2014:2095  x  
Da Silva 03/07/ 2014 C-189/13 2014:2043  x  
Mahdi 05/06/2014 C-146/14 PPU 2014:1320  x  
Filev & Osmani 19/09/2013 C-297/12 2013:569  x  
G. & R. 10/09/2013 C-383/13 PPU 2013:533  x  
Arslan 30/05/2013 C-534/11 2013:343  x  
Mbaye 21/03/ 2013 C-522/11 2013:190  x  
Sagor 06/12/2012 C-430/11 2012:277  x  
Achughbabian 06/12/2011 C-329/11 2011:807  x  
El Dridi 28/04/2011

C-61/11 PPU

2011:268  x  
Kadzoev 30/11/2009 C-357/09 PPU 2009:741  x  
Pending cases  
M.D. / HU AG:24/11/2022 C-528/21 2022:933 Art 5+11  
C.D. / CZ   C-257/22   Art 4(2), Charta Art 2, 4, 19  
P.L. / BE   C-56/22   Art 5, 6, 13  
X.X.X. / BELG   C-711/21
C-712/21
  Art 5  
A.A. / AUT   C-663/21   Art 5, 6, 8, 9  

↑ TOP